Big Dams
and their Environmental Impacts ![]()
| "The cost of
building dams is always underestimated-- There's erosion of the delta that the river has created, There's fertile soil below the dam that's likely to be looted, And the tangled mat of forest that has got to be uprooted. There's disappointing yield of fish, beyond the first explosion; --Kenneth E. Boulding, "The Ballad of Ecological Awareness," in The Careless Technology, ed. by M. Taghi Favar and John P. Milton, 1972. |
Video shown in class
Large Dams, False Promises (35 min.) -- Features three dams: Sardar Sarovar (India), Three Gorges (China) and Balbina (Brazil). Illustrates the immeasurable destruction large dams cause to ecosystems and riverine communities. Writer and producer: David Phinney; executive producer: Andrea Torrice; 35 minutes. (Information about the video's availability outside of Geography 100)
Assigned outside reading
Miller, pp. 112; 287-288
Assigned online reading
The Environmental Impacts of Large Dams, Lori Pottinger, International Rivers Network, 1997 -- describes the connections between land and surface water, and how dams can disrupt these links. [1,300 words]
Some Solutions to Big Dams
Cracks in the Dams -- "For most of this century, politicians eagerly rushed in, amid cheering crowds, to claim credit for the construction of dams. They built dams for barge traffic, for electricity, for irrigation, for drinking water, for flood control. In America alone, 75,000 dams have been built. But the public is now learning that society has paid a steadily accumulating price for these projects. Fish spawning runs have been destroyed, flows have become nonseasonal, wedges of sediment have piled up behind structures, and delta wetlands have been degraded by a lack of fresh water and by an intrusion of saltwater. Meanwhile, many of the dams have not provided the promised benefits. They were built with taxpayer subsidies, then justified by dubious cost-benefit projections.
That is why on June 17, 1997, Interior Secretary Bruce Babbitt took the first crack with a sledgehammer to dismantle the first of four dams on the Menominee River flowing between Wisconsin and Michigan. By August 4, 1998, six more had been removed... Active campaigns are now under way to demolish four dams on the Snake River and the Savage Rapids dam in Oregon and to drain the Powell reservoir on the Colorado River to restore Glen Canyon." --Probe Alert, News Brief, October 1998
Questions to answer concerning big
dams:
1. What country built the first gigantic dams and approximately when? --Name one dam as an early example. (Info from video)
2. (a) About how many large dams (most of which were built in the past five decades) now obstruct the world's rivers? (b) About how many of these big dams are in the United States?
3. The world's largest water impoundment is the ___________ Reservoir behind _________________ Dam, in the country of _____________ .
4. Concisely, how does a big dam typically impact each of the following aspects of a river? (a) the flow of water, including floods; (b) sediment load, erosion, and deposition; (c) habitat for freshwater plants and animals; (d) the coastline where it empties; (e) human settlement in the valley:
5. What is an estuary, why is it ecologically important, and typically how is it affected by dams?
6. Today what is the situation in the U.S. concerning the construction and/or removal of large dams?
7. Why do you think the World Bank has continued to promote and fund big dams even though (according to Patrick McCully) many, "have failed to meet their objectives, caused significant environmental and social damage, and pushed borrowers further into debt"?
8. For each of the following three cases, specify what groups of people typically benefit the most from international loans (such as those from the World Bank) for big dam construction, and what people benefit the least or are harmed: (a) Sardar Sarovar and other big dams on the Narmada River, (b) Balbina Dam, and (c) Three Gorges Dam (Info from video)
|
|
A few
gigantic dams, |
Many small
dams, |
| "I am one with thee, and who knows what may avail a crowbar against that Billerica dam?" --Henry David Thoreau, on committing eco-sabotage, A Week on the Concord and Merrimack Rivers, 1849 |
Optional Resources concerning Big Dams
Thomas Detwyler maintains this page (tdetwyle@uwsp.edu)
Last updated 8 June 2001