Introduction
The nations of the
world are becoming increasingly interdependent from an economic perspective.
Products and services are being designed, produced, distributed, and
marketed on a global basis. Business opportunity and competition do not end
at the water's edge; whether that water is the Pacific Ocean or
Lake Michigan. Foreign trade and international finance have
arrived in the heartland of America, and concern with exports, imports, and
foreign investment have made the Central Wisconsin
economy a more diverse and complex organization.
This report will
describe recent trends in U.S.
foreign economic activity, and it will emphasize the benefits and costs of
this process to the state of
Wisconsin
and to our own region. The benefits of foreign trade include a greater
variety of consumer goods for Central Wisconsin
residents, and more choice for us in terms of price and quality. Local
businesses have extended their markets through exports, and several firms
have improved their competitiveness by importing materials and equipment.
Costs of becoming involved with foreign trade include increased
transportation costs, volatile exchange rates, more indirect marketing
procedures, and more complex financial arrangements.
National Trends
In the 1980s, the
merchandise balance of trade deficit has become the ultimate indicator of United States
economic performance. Journalists, stock market speculators, and government
officials anxiously await the release of each month's figures. Figure 1
shows the trend in this measure in current prices and adjusted for
inflation.
If ten economists were
arguing over the "cause" of the balance of trade deficit, they would come up
with twenty plausible hypotheses. My own view is that national trends in
U.S.
economic structure, large deficits in the federal government budget, and
reluctance to save by the American public are responsible for most of the
balance of trade deficit. Please note the popular explanations of our trade
deficit that I did not cite: lack of technological progress, poor
management, greedy and uncooperative unions unfair trade practices of other
nations, volatile foreign exchange markets, and lack of direction by
government. The problem with these "explanations" is that either they are
inconsistent with the data or they existed long before there was a balance
of trade problem.
The eagerness of
foreigners to invest in
America
is closely correlated with our trade deficit. Whether this significant
and expanding phenomenon is a cause or a result of our trade situation
is debated by experts, but the fact remains that capital inflows are
largely financing our excess of imports over exports. Figure 2 indicates
that America's new status as the world's
largest debtor nation is directly correlated with the attractiveness of
our financial markets to international investors.
Wisconsin's
International Economic Performance
Our state has
become involved in many aspects of the global economy. In 1987 Wisconsin's exports were $3.07 billion, and
its imports were $2.30 billion. Although data on a state's foreign
transactions are not precise, Wisconsin's
trade performance is noteworthy in a year when the United States ran a large deficit. A
surplus of $773 million is a healthy accomplishment for a state that is
located in the Midwest. 1988 represents
a continuation of this trend with a surplus of $363 million during the
first six months. Wisconsin's
leading export industries are non-electrical and electrical machinery,
primary metals, and fabricated metals. Export related jobs account for
over 15 percent of employment in these industries.
The controversial
phenomenon of foreign investment is highly significant for Wisconsin. Whether capital flows from abroad
are welcomed as contributing to job creation and economic development,
or criticized as increasing foreign influence on the American economy, Wisconsin is getting its
share. In 1986 $3.2 billion of Wisconsin's
property was owned by foreigners, and over 57,000
Wisconsin
workers were employed by foreign controlled firms (figure 3). Most
controversial of all, 95,000 acres of Wisconsin
land were owned by foreign interests.
Although these
figures are striking, employment of U.S.
workers by foreign affiliates accounts for only 3.5 percent of the labor
force, and for Wisconsin
that percentage is no higher than in 1980. Acquisition of agricultural
land by foreign interests has slowed, reflecting the recent investment
performance of that industry. Less than 1 % of state land is owned by
foreigners.
State government in Wisconsin is actively
promoting foreign trade and reverse investment. The Bureau of
International Development in
Madison
is an important component of this effort with an annual budget of over
$1.5 million. Wisconsin has established
foreign trade offices in Frankfurt, Germany and Hong Kong, and is adding others in South Korea and Japan. Our state is providing
financial, technical, and promotional assistance to potential exporting
firms. The most visible activities include frequent trade missions to
Europe and Asia led by the Governor.
Competition among
states for marketing goods abroad is intense. At least 30 other states
are operating foreign trade offices in 15 nations. Twenty-three states
have passed legislation creating arrangements to provide financial
assistance to exporters. The National Association of State Development
Agencies estimates that states now spend close to $40 million per year
on export promotion, and that figure has been increasing at an annual
rate of 15 percent.
International Economic Activity in
Central Wisconsin
In preparation for
this special report, the Central Wisconsin Economic Research Bureau
conducted a survey of business firms in Marathon,
Portage, and Wood counties. Of the 34 manufacturing
companies interviewed, 32 or 94 percent indicated at least some
involvement with international trade or foreign investment. As shown in
Table 1, 79 percent of these Central Wisconsin
firms engaged in some exporting in recent years. Canada was the most frequently mentioned destination,
and for many of these companies exports accounted for a small percentage
of their total output.
FIGURE 3
WISCONSIN
WORKERS EMPLOYED BY
FOREIGN CONTROLLED FIRMS in 1987
TABLE
1
SURVEY OF CENTRAL WISCONSIN FIRMS
|
Question
|
Response
|
|
|
|
Yes
|
No
|
No Response
|
|
1. Have you
exported recently?
|
79%
|
21 %
|
0%
|
|
2. Do you
use imports in your business?
|
71 %
|
29%
|
0%
|
|
3. Does
foreign investment provide
|
26%
|
68%
|
6%
|
|
ownership or
financing for your firm?
|
|
|
|
|
4. Has the
ownership of your firm
|
24%
|
68%
|
9%
|
|
invested in foreign
enterprise?
|
|
|
|
|
5. Have
government agencies assisted your firm?
|
21 %
|
71 %
|
9%
|
|
6. Would
you like to expand foreign sales?
|
79%
|
15%
|
6%
|
Exports from this
region include: agricultural machinery and equipment, furniture, paper,
electrical machinery, food products (raw and processed), construction
components, industrial equipment, tools, and recreational products.
Seventy-one percent
of the companies surveyed use some imported raw materials, processed
goods, or equipment in their business. Their reasons for using foreign
sources included price, quality, and availability in the few cases where
no comparable American product could be obtained.
A minority but
significant number of these firms would qualify as participating in some
form of foreign investment. Several area firms are branches or
affiliates of national or multinational enterprises with full
participation in the global economy.
Only 21 percent of
the respondents indicated that they have received any help or
encouragement from federal or state government agencies in their
international activities. Finally, the vast majority were enthusiastic
about the prospect of increasing their foreign trade involvement in the
near future.
The CWERB has
documented a high degree of participation and interest in foreign trade
among Central Wisconsin
firms. However, our interviews revealed significant barriers to further
expansion. First, transportation costs of shipping some manufactured
products from our region are high relative to the weight and value of
these goods. This situation along with unfavorable exchange rates,
creates problems of cost competitiveness. Second, several smaller firms
began exporting through unsolicited orders from abroad. This "over the
transom" business may not lead to a systematic, effective international
marketing effort. In fact, identifying sales representatives in foreign
markets has been one of the difficulties faced by local manufacturers.
Third, many potential exporters lack knowledge and experience in the
financial aspects of foreign trade. Arranging payment and credit terms
for foreign buyers was mentioned as a significant concern.
Conclusions
Clearly, the global
economy extends to the Central Wisconsin Region. Local firms are
profiting by export sales, foreign sources of materials and equipment,
and financial arrangements with multinational enterprises. The downside
of international activity is increasing competition and uncertainty.
Local firms cited concerns with transportation costs, exchange rate
fluctuations, foreign marketing, and complex financing terms.
Information and
assistance for potential exporters can come from several sources:
federal and state government agencies, providers of consulting and
business services, and voluntary associations (Table 2). However, our
evidence indicates an information gap still exists that creates a
barrier to the expansion of export sales for smaller firms.
TABLE
2
INTERNATIONAL TRADE ORGANIZATIONS
District Export Council
Jerry D. Maahs, Chair c/o
Alto-Shaam, Inc.
W164 N9221 Water St.
Menomonee
Falls,
WI 53051
(414) 251-3800
U.S.
Department of Commerce
International Trade Administration
District Office
517 E.
Wisconsin Ave.
Milwaukee,
WI 53202
Tel: (414) 291-3473
Waukesha
County Technical College
800 Main St.
James K. Eigenfeld, Director
School
of International
Trade
Barbara Moebius, Project Manager,
International
Trade Technical Center
Pewaukee,
WI 53072
(414) 691-5230
Wisconsin
Department of Agriculture,
Trade and Consumer Protection
International
Agri-business
Center
801 W. Badger Road
P.O. Box
8911
Madison,
WI 53708
(608) 266-2221
Fax: (608) 266-1300
Wisconsin
Department of Development
Bureau of International Development
123 W. Washington Ave.
P.O. Box
7970
Madison,
WI 53707
(608) 266-1480
Fax: (608) 267-2829
Telex: 882108 WI DEPT DEV UD
Wisconsin World Trade
Center Inc.
Pfister Hotel
424 E. Wisconsin
Ave.
Milwaukee,
WI 53202
(414) 274-3840
Fax: (414) 274-3846
Central Wisconsin
World Trade Association
Richard B. Judy, President
P.O. Box
803
Stevens Point,
WI 54481
(715) 346-3774/2728
Central Wisconsin
Business Development Center
George E. Seyfarth, Director
UW-Stevens Point
Stevens Point,
WI 54481
(715) 346-2004
Northcentral
Technical
College
Business Division
Small Business Management Program
Business Outreach
Fred Boller, Director
1000 Campus Drive
Wausau,
WI 54401
(715) 675-3331 ext. 360